At the risk of sounding old with a “back in my day” soliloquy about how different nonprofit work was ten years ago, when I started in case management, our flyers for youth classes were created in Publisher. A few years later, using Canva was a big move, and we felt like the quality of our work improved vastly while also becoming easier and faster. Now, AI has entered the picture, and I often find myself asking: Where do we draw the line?

In nonprofit social services, our work is people. People choose to come into our offices for help when they could certainly use a computer to try to find answers, whether on a smartphone or a desktop at the local library. So why do they contact us? I believe human connection is not dead (at least not yet), and there is no substitute for the relationships we build with clients, donors, and our community.

AI is certainly very useful, don’t get me wrong! I am excited to see where the future of AI leads within our work and society as a whole. It can be a great collaborator, editor, and sounding board. It can reduce tedious tasks, streamline workflows, keep staff engaged in the services that matter, and that helps grant dollars go further. A report by The Center for Effective Philanthropy found that well over half of surveyed nonprofits use AI in their communications, internal productivity, and fundraising. Still, concerns remain around misinformation and bias, data security, and a general lack of understanding about how to use it effectively.

As we embrace these new tools, we must also make sure we don’t come across as fake, disingenuous, or disengaged. Here are a few areas where we should be intentional about keeping the human element:

  • Visuals and program advertisements: Your nonprofit is unique, and your materials should reflect that. Let staff talents and personality shine through rather than relying on all generic, AI-generated content.
  • Donor relationships: A phone call or personal visit can mean much more than an automated text. There are ways to incorporate AI into fundraising to save time while still being authentic and mission-driven. Nonprofit for Good has webinars and articles about AI-driven SMS tools that enhance the conversation, not detract from it, retaining donor trust and interest.
  • Client relationships: There is no substitute for having a real person to call when you need help, who can listen, understand your circumstances, and help you navigate your options. I discussed the importance of permanent connections to foster youth in a previous post, and AI cannot replace that person-centered work.
  • Putting heart into the meaningful work: Consider areas where the work is impactful, for both clients and staff, and keep those areas human. As a case manager, I enjoyed creating materials including presentations and activities for our clients because it was an area to connect and show creativity. It would have been unfortunate if those opportunities for using imagination and interacting with others became bland and predictable.

AI is a tool, not a replacement for the people behind the mission. As nonprofits, we should embrace opportunities to work smarter, but never lose sight of what makes our work meaningful in the first place: people helping people.

How are you incorporating AI into your work? Where do you think it helps, and where should we draw the line? I’d love to hear your thoughts!

One response to “Keeping the Human in Human Services”

  1. Kristina Bozanich Avatar
    Kristina Bozanich

    This is the same for me across my industry as well! I do marketing and I land in the place where AI is great for the tedious stuff and terrible at… well the obvious,… being human. In making a relationship with a donor, it has to be genuine and authentic which is why we do trust people over AI. I agree that we let AI take the boring parts so people get more time for the human parts, but not the other way around.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

I’m Lindsey

Working toward lasting community change through more than good intentions

Let’s connect

Blogroll


Trust Your Gut (But I Can't!)
Trust Your Gut (But I Can’t!)
Life with Ulcerative Colitis

Supporting Healthier Animals & Developing Successful People
Supporting Healthier Animals & Developing Successful People
Stewardship in business, leadership in life.

Ann Green’s Nonprofit Blog
Advice and Resources to Help Nonprofit Organizations and Professionals Succeed

Whole Story Solutions, LLC
Whole Story Solutions, LLC
helping nonprofits tell stories that spark lasting partnerships

Nonprofit Tech for Good
A Digital Marketing and Fundraising Resource for Nonprofits

Ryan Cole Rodriquez
Ryan Cole Rodriquez
Making sense of how technology changes what we create, value, and experience.

Lets Talk Business
Lets Talk Business
By Kristine Cambunga